Hooray! Obama Didn’t (exactly) Lie

If you like your health care plan, you can keep your health care plan.

Pres. Obama, various dates, August, 2009

 

As with car sales pitches, voters are advised to listen to politicians’ promises carefully before buying in. Read the fine print; read between the lines; caveat emptor. Listening to Pres. Obama’s health care speeches throughout 2009, one could wrongly conclude that he was promising that consumers could keep their old system of healthcare. Tell that today to anyone seeking to insure a child starting September 23, the date upon which Obamacare will effectively outlaw individual coverage of children’s healthcare.

Starting September 23, Obamacare outlaws denying coverage to children based on preexisting medical conditions. While that sounds nice, the effect is that nearly every provider of individual children’s healthcare has ceased to write new policies, and the remaining few will probably also drop out of the market. The insurers’ reasoning is simple – children are usually quite healthy, except for the expensive few who are not. If parents are allowed to wait to buy insurance until after their children are afflicted with tragic diseases, the risk pool will be over weighted with very expensive clients. By outlawing the screening of new clients before accepting them, the statistical methods that allow for risk sharing become meaningless. Because of the government mandate, there is no way to make a profit, so insurance companies are leaving the market.

Now Obama did not exactly lie here. He said “If you like your health care plan,” not “if you want your neighbor’s health care plan.” Those children lucky enough to be born before September 2010 might still keep their insurance; too bad for the new crop. Of course Obama deceived voters by not disclosing that Obamacare would deny insurance to young people. He promised coverage for 30 million people, most of whom choose to not buy the insurance they could afford, but he forgot to mention the responsible people who would like to buy insurance but now cannot.

While denying health insurance to children is bad policy, it does not stop there. The same preexisting condition law will soon take effect for everyone. Obamacare will bar insurers from writing new individual policies to everyone. Again, you can” keep your health care plan,” but if you are a young person looking for new coverage, tough luck.

Look for the Obama administration to fault the insurance companies and their evil profit motive. Obama will surely call for a public option to cover those unfortunate enough to seek individual insurance after Obamacare outlawed it. Young people will have no real choice but to buy government backed insurance. With old people already on social healthcare since the 1960′s, it will only take a matter of a few decades before everyone is forced into government single provider health care.

Obama may have been popular with young people in 2008, but few of them likely realized that Obamacare would be a continuation of the government’s policy of robbing relatively poor young people to pay for entitlements for relatively wealthy old people. As with Social Security, Medicare and Obamacare effectively transfer wealth from young workers to retirees who should have prepared for their own needs. The government currently transfers about 14% of each worker’s earnings to the older generations’ pockets, often leaving the young workers incapable of preparing for their own retirement. Fully socialized medicine, thanks to Obamacare, is a continuation of the enslavement of younger workers to benefit the fat baby-boom voter block.

So, Obama did not exactly lie when he pitched his socialized medicine plan. Sure, Obamacare is an injustice to responsible individuals who want to buy the health coverage that suites their needs. Sure, Obamacare is a crafty trap that forces people to choose a single payer government system. Obama never said it wasn’t. Voters just didn’t read the fine print.

Live Like Obama Never Happened

As Shout Bits completes its second year of commentary, some readers have justly criticized it for becoming more negative in the face of Washington’s vigorous assault on freedom and prosperity. Shout Bits can only plead that it had no idea how radical and high-handed Pres. Obama would be. A leftist, certainly, but Obama has also shredded property rights (e.g. the Chrysler theft and BP shakedown) and any semblance of ethics (the various blatant payoffs to lawmakers to enact socialized medicine). It is hard to remain optimistic even in the greatest nation. Still, here are some words of hope: everything Obama has done will be undone eventually, and the best advice is to live like Obama never happened.

Of course Obama and his Democrat lieutenants have dealt a serious blow to the US with their regulation, spending, and socialist takeovers, but their excesses are nothing new. Countries like Russia already tried the collectivist route and failed. Other countries like Greece and much of Old Europe tried socialism-light, and are only now failing. Obama’s socialist experiment comes very late to the party, with the US emulating Europe just as Europe is ready to give in and admit failure. While it has taken 60 to 70 years for Europe’s socialist experiment to fail, Obama’s experiment will not last nearly as long. Europe socialized long before its debts became un-payable, but the US enacted the final piece of socialist paradise when its debts were already clearly out of hand. The bill for Washington excess will likely come due before Obamacare even fully takes effect.

Reality will force the failure and repeal of everything Obama has done, along with the creeping socialist agenda of nearly every modern President before him. If not, the US itself will fail like Greece. Either way Obama’s theft or destruction of the US system of freedom and prosperity will not stand even to the end of the new decade. As an absolute certainty, something will change, and that is good news.

Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged tells the story of a capitalist who gave up on a world eerily like Obama’s US. Galt, Shrugged’s hero, built a new liberal paradise of capitalism and property rights. Galt’s hidden mountain paradise, however, is as impractical as Rand’s book is tedious. Outside of idealized fiction there is simply no choice but to carry on.

Obama’s policies, every one, will fail and be abandoned. Whether Obama is replaced with a return to a rule of law, individual rights, and a capitalist system or anarchy is the choice of businesspeople and libertarians. Even though Obamacare ironically encourages people to drop their health care, pay for it anyway. Even though Obama will double the taxes on investments next year, invest in the US’s future. Even though Obama’s spending squeezes the profit out of employing people, look for talent among the unemployed. Even though Obama has claimed the lion’s prize of the wealth of this nation, for now accept what little Washington has yet to claim. If only for show, keep the capitalist engine running because someday soon the US will abandon socialism and today’s optimists will be best poised to prosper.

In other words, keep living like Obama never happened because collectivist experiments always fail and someone always emerges from the wreckage to restore prosperity. Accepting Washington as the new guardian of our lives will only extend Obama’s lost years.

Endless Stimulus

Last week, Washington released the employment news, and it was bad. Nearly all the jobs added in May were from temporary government hires. While unemployment went down by a fraction, it was due to hundreds of thousands of people giving up on finding work. Without the effects of the Census hires, the economy nearly went backward. Naturally, the statists in Washington are promising more stimuli. Washington wants more stimuli on top of Stimulus 1, Stimulus 2 (the jobs bill), TARP, free money for banks, and the union bailout bill. Surely nobody in Washington thinks even more will help.

In reality, stimulus, or deficit spending, is the lifeblood of Washington politics. Overspending is how statists gain and expand their power, and a lingering recession is simply today’s excuse for Washington’s perennial waste and corruption. When times were good, progressives like Pres. Bush (43) passed a socialized prescription medicine law. Rain or shine, Washington is always a growth industry.

With trillions in stimulus, why is the economy not adding jobs? How could stimulus be such a failure? This blog argued that stimulus actually retards growth and job creation by artificially directing resources to unproductive projects. Stimulus is not the only tool Washington uses to retard economic growth. When it comes to ruining the American dream, Pres. Obama has a few more tricks up his sleeve.

Pres. Obama, barring some miracle, will by inaction enact the largest tax increase in human history on January 1, 2011. Capital gains and dividend taxes will nearly double. Income taxes will go up by about five percentage points. With huge new tax bills coming due for small businesses that pay according to the personal tax schedule, money that could go to growing their business will go to Washington. Further, consumers know that their taxes explode next year – a major disincentive to spend or invest.

Obama and Interior Secretary Salazar are putting the squeeze on energy. New domestic offshore oil will have to wait until a new administration writes stronger safety regulations. Meanwhile Brazil will benefit from the jobs and investment that come from oil exploration that could be done in the US. Salazar has not confined his assault on domestic energy production to offshore oil. He has also killed thousands of jobs in the West by denying natural gas and shale oil exploration. Of course drilling in a tiny remote portion of ANWR was always off the table. Regulation and kowtowing to environmental lobbies did not prevent the Gulf spill, but it has needlessly exported jobs and investment.

In the housing sector, Obama has simultaneously paid the middle class up to $8,000 to buy a new house, while telling bankers that if they make a loan they may be powerless to enforce their contractual right to foreclose. While an $8,000 incentive was nice, the main obstacle to home ownership remains the lack of a functioning market in financing. Obama has trotted out numerous plans that essentially prevent banks from foreclosing on unpaid notes. Banks already have powerful incentives to not foreclose, but they must have foreclosure as a last resort or else they cannot clear bad assets and eventually make new loans. Obama is replicating the Japanese ‘lost decade’ of bank malaise by trying to save what sometimes cannot be saved. In normal economies, construction activity accounts for 10% of the US economy, but Obama, Rep. Frank and Sen. Dodd, are killing this sector’s recovery with their meddling.

Perhaps Obama’s greatest blow to job creation has been his unpopular socialized medicine law. Not even experts have a clue how the 2,600 pages of Obamacare will be implemented. While everyone knows it will be expensive, no reasonable projection yet exists. Will private sector healthcare costs rise to the level of union or government plans? Will the cost effective HSA based plans be effectively outlawed, doubling or tripling their sponsor’s costs? Quite probably healthcare costs will be unrecognizably higher when Obamacare fully takes effect. With unknowable mandates being forced onto even small employers, job creation will be clouded for years to come. While Obama, Speaker Pelosi, and Majority Leader Reid used vagueness and obfuscation to pass socialized medicine, that very tactic is killing job creation.

The lingering jobs recession is a creation of Washington. Without multiple stimuli, heavy anti-industrial regulation, and expanded socialism, the jobs market would have long ago corrected itself. How many years of economic stagnation and European levels of unemployment will it take to prove that Washington is solely to blame for the US’s jobs problem? The best medicine is no stimulus, less regulation, and especially the repeal of Obamacare. Another stimulus at this point means more pain for Americans who would like to work but cannot.